All curvy school teacher Marlee Simpson wants for Valentines is a toe-curling snuggle buddy who will steal her heart and leave her wanting for more. But after two years of spending Valentines night alone she’s not holding out much hope for this one either.
Wouldn’t it be great if you could just write Cupid a letter, a la Santa style, and ask for the man of your dreams? Marlee does just that one cold Tennessee night as she’s falling to sleep. She’s not expecting the stylish, bald man in the Armani suit dripping with jewels who claims to be the one and only Cupid! When he shows up in the middle of the night at her home and shoots her with an arrow through the heart that disappears in a cloud of glitter, Marlee awakes thinking she’s had a nightmare from some bad yogurt.
Then she meets the new gym teacher and her new neighbor, Noah Hawks, and she starts to believe maybe Cupid was real after all. Noah’s almost too good to be true. Will he disappear in a cloud of glitter after Valentines, or will the man of her dreams stick around and keep her warm?